21500-21504 Indian Bayou Dr, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

Home For Sale - $2,990,000




AGENT

CAPRICE KRUMSICK TEAM

Caprice@caprice-florida-realtor.com

(239) 677-7141

Realty One Group MVP

Julia Gerold

julia@caprice-florida-realtor.com

(239) 297-6617

Realty One Group MVP

Caprice Krumsick


PROPERTY VIDEO



GALLERY

PROPERTY INFO


IN SQ.FT
LIVING AREA

6,101


NUMBER OF
BEDROOMS

6


NUMBER OF
BATHROOMS

4 Full


PARKING
GARAGE

8


YEAR
BUILT

1997

Other Rooms: great rooms


**Rare Bayfront Duplex Opportunity | Fort Myers Beach**


Welcome to a truly unique bayfront duplex offering the best of Southwest Florida living—direct boating access paired with a short stroll to the beach.


Tucked away at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this impressive property features over **6,100 square feet under air**, thoughtfully designed across three levels and built on solid concrete pilings.


Recently and professionally remodeled after hurricane damage, the home now includes **new, code-compliant hurricane shutters** and a range of valuable upgrades throughout.


From the moment you step inside, you’ll notice the abundance of natural light and **expansive bay views**, enhanced by large windows and multiple balconies on every level.


Each unit offers an ideal layout:


On the **top floor**, you’ll find a spacious primary suite complete with a private balcony, dual walk-in closets, and a generous bathroom.


The **second level** features two additional bedrooms connected by a Jack & Jill bathroom—perfect for guests or family.

The **main living area** showcases an open-concept design with kitchen, dining, and a dramatic two-story great room that flows seamlessly onto a waterfront balcony.


On the **ground level**, you’ll find ample garage space with room for multiple vehicles and storage.


This property offers exceptional flexibility—live in one unit and rent the other, create a high-performing short- or long-term rental investment, or combine both units through existing interior access points on every level.


Previously operated as a successful vacation rental, the property is ready to be reintroduced into a rental program.


Offered **turnkey furnished**—with select exclusions—this home is move-in or rental ready.


Recent upgrades include:


* New metal roof

* Updated A/C systems

* Modern vinyl flooring

* Impact sliding doors in primary suites

* Fully resurfaced pool with new tile and spa

* New pool equipment


Additional highlights:


* Elevator shaft in place (currently non-operational)

* Mangrove trimming permit already completed

* Three separate parcel IDs per county records


Please note: The dock was damaged during Hurricane Ian and will require replacement—details are available upon request. The property is being sold as-is.


This is a rare opportunity to own a versatile waterfront property in one of Fort Myers Beach’s most desirable locations.


**Showings by appointment only.**




CITY VIDEO

Location

AGENT

CAPRICE KRUMSICK TEAM

Caprice@caprice-florida-realtor.com

(239) 677-7141

Julia Gerold

julia@caprice-florida-realtor.com

(239) 297-6617